Tinted eleven blocks up
Benjamin Moore paint and custom tinting
Custom tinting happens at our sister store on First Avenue, the authorized Benjamin Moore dealer, so the machine, the base stock and the color books are all up there. Bring a color name or number, or bring a chip, a lid or a piece of trim to match.
Type any color from any brand. We mix it in Benjamin Moore paint.
Searching Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams, Behr, Farrow & Ball, PPG, Valspar, Dunn-Edwards and RAL. Don't see your color? Type it in anyway and we will match it. Have a chip, a lid or a painted sample? Bring it to NY Paint and Hardware at 1668 First Ave and we will read it on the spectrophotometer.
Custom color
Benjamin Moore Advance Custom Color
From $33.99
Benjamin Moore Aura Bath & Spa Custom Color
From $31.99
Benjamin Moore Aura Custom Color
From $31.99
Benjamin Moore ben Custom Color
From $20.99
Benjamin Moore Regal Select Custom Color
From $24.99
Benjamin Moore Super Hide Custom Color
From $36.99
Benjamin Moore Ultra Spec Scuff-X Custom Color
From $49.99
Ready mixed whites and colors
Benjamin Moore Advance Ready-Mix Colors
From $34.99
Benjamin Moore Advance White
From $34.99
Benjamin Moore Aura White
From $80.99
Benjamin Moore ben White
From $20.99
Benjamin Moore Regal Select Ready-Mix Colors
From $26.99
Benjamin Moore Regal Select White
From $26.99
Benjamin Moore Ultra Spec Scuff-X Ready-Mix Colors
From $49.99
Benjamin Moore Ultra Spec Scuff-X White
From $49.99
Primers
Exterior
Color tools
Specialty
- Full Benjamin Moore line, tinted to any color
- Contractor pricing on 5-gallon pails
- Brushes, rollers, tape and sundries at 1587
Ask about a color
Tell us what you need and a person from the counter will call you back.
How it works
Bring it in or send the form
Come to the counter at 1587 First Avenue, or send the details through the form on this page and we will call you back.
We confirm price and timing before any work
Nothing starts until you have a number and a date from us. If we cannot do it, we say so and point you somewhere that can.
Pick up at 1587 First Avenue or ask about delivery
Most work is collected at the counter. Local delivery is available on the same terms as the rest of the store.
Counter people who do the work
Paint supply is handled in the store by the same people who sell the parts, so you get one answer, not a referral.
Upper East Side, on foot
We are on First Avenue between 82nd and 83rd. Most jobs on the block can drop off and collect the same trip.
Trade pricing on the parts
Open a Pro account and the materials that go with the job price at your account rate at the register.
Where we are
First Ave Supply
1587 First Avenue
New York, NY 10028
We serve the Upper East Side, Yorkville, Carnegie Hill, Lenox Hill and all of Manhattan.
Local delivery is $35 in Manhattan and $65 outside it, free in Manhattan over $250, with same-day on in-stock items ordered by 10am.
- Monday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Tuesday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Wednesday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Thursday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Friday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Saturday
- 8:00am to 6:30pm
- Sunday
- 10:00am to 6:30pm
Shop related
Questions
Where is the paint tinted?
Full Benjamin Moore line, tinted to any color while you wait, at the authorized dealer eleven blocks up from 1587.
What do I bring to match a color?
A color name or number is best. A chip, a lid or a piece of trim also works.
What paint supplies are at 1587?
Brushes, rollers, tape, spackle, drop cloths and thinners are on the shelf here in Paint and Sundries.
Is there contractor pricing?
Yes, on 5-gallon pails. Ask at the counter or open a Pro account.
Call the counter at (212) 535-8400.